Skip to main content
Solved

Why the Stop Radius is negative in Prescription Data?

  • September 26, 2023
  • 7 replies
  • 164 views

Yang.Yongtao
Fully Spectral
Forum|alt.badge.img

Hello,

 As a new beginner to Zemax, I am not sure whether it is normal to get a negative stop radius in Prescription Data

below is part of my design result and in lens data the stop is a fixed R 5.75

my question is 

  1. Why the stop radius here is a negative one? but the system aperture  as I set is positive
  2. is it normal to get a negative stop radius in the prescription data?

 

 

 

Thank you !

 

Best answer by Jeff.Wilde

Actually, it seems like the sign of the stop radius is related to the sign of the paraxial magnification between the stop plane and entrance pupil.  Here’s the same example, but this time the “Marginal and Chief Ray Only” option is selected in the layout window…

 

For negative entrance pupil magnification, a marginal ray coming from the top of the EP arrives at the bottom of the stop -- but in this case the marginal ray is propagating in the downward direction when viewed in the layout window.

 

Regards,

Jeff

View original
Did this topic help you find an answer to your question?

7 replies

David.Nguyen
Luminary
Forum|alt.badge.img+2
  • Luminary
  • 1094 replies
  • September 26, 2023

Hi @Yang.Yongtao,

 

Not a complete answer, but I can reproduce the negative Stop Radius by having two consecutive 4f systems where the center of the second 4is the Stop Surface:

It could have to do with how the Stop Radius is calculated in the prescription report, if one takes the marginal ray that first goes upwards (positvie values of Y), it ends up having a negative Y intercept with the Stop Surface. I’ve tried to highlight this phenomenon in this figure:

Hence the negative Stop Radius reported. I think its only in the prescription report though, are you concerned about this value?

I hope this helps, and take care,


David


Mark.Nicholson
Luminary
Forum|alt.badge.img+3

I think that’s a bug, although of a very minor kind. Since r=SQRT(x^2 + y^2) it should never have a sign. I suspect OS is reporting the y-value of the marginal ray height without taking the absolute part.


Jeff.Wilde
Luminary
Forum|alt.badge.img+3
  • Luminary
  • 491 replies
  • September 26, 2023

I find that the stop radius is positive when the stop is located at a paraxial collimating lens surface, but turns negative if the stop is moved slightly downstream….  Does look like some sort of minor bug.

 

Regards,

Jeff


Mark.Nicholson
Luminary
Forum|alt.badge.img+3

Ooohhh, good call!


Jeff.Wilde
Luminary
Forum|alt.badge.img+3
  • Luminary
  • 491 replies
  • Answer
  • September 26, 2023

Actually, it seems like the sign of the stop radius is related to the sign of the paraxial magnification between the stop plane and entrance pupil.  Here’s the same example, but this time the “Marginal and Chief Ray Only” option is selected in the layout window…

 

For negative entrance pupil magnification, a marginal ray coming from the top of the EP arrives at the bottom of the stop -- but in this case the marginal ray is propagating in the downward direction when viewed in the layout window.

 

Regards,

Jeff


Yang.Yongtao
Fully Spectral
Forum|alt.badge.img
  • Author
  • Fully Spectral
  • 58 replies
  • October 2, 2023
David.Nguyen wrote:

Hi @Yang.Yongtao,

 

Not a complete answer, but I can reproduce the negative Stop Radius by having two consecutive 4f systems where the center of the second 4is the Stop Surface:

It could have to do with how the Stop Radius is calculated in the prescription report, if one takes the marginal ray that first goes upwards (positvie values of Y), it ends up having a negative Y intercept with the Stop Surface. I’ve tried to highlight this phenomenon in this figure:

Hence the negative Stop Radius reported. I think its only in the prescription report though, are you concerned about this value?

I hope this helps, and take care,


David

hi David

 Thanks !

 The highlight you showed is really understandable.

Best Regards!

Yang

 


Yang.Yongtao
Fully Spectral
Forum|alt.badge.img
  • Author
  • Fully Spectral
  • 58 replies
  • October 2, 2023

Thank you all!

I learned a lot from you


Reply


Cookie policy

We use cookies to enhance and personalize your experience. If you accept you agree to our full cookie policy. Learn more about our cookies.

 
Cookie settings