Other than optimization speed, RELI seems to work fine, this is just a minor gripe that I realize might have a clever solution.
Thanks!
Best answer by Mark.Nicholson
View original
Optimization alternative to RELI for relative illumination.
I notice that adding RELI to my merit functions significantly slows down the optimization speed. Is there an alternative for relative illumination optimization that is more computationally efficient? My application is general imaging lens design/optimization.
Other than optimization speed, RELI seems to work fine, this is just a minor gripe that I realize might have a clever solution.
Thanks!
Other than optimization speed, RELI seems to work fine, this is just a minor gripe that I realize might have a clever solution.
Thanks!
Userlevel 7
+3
Hi Sean,
RELI is a fairly big calculation, so I can see why it impacts speed. I'd suggest using it with an OPGT/OPLT operand so that you constrain it to be within a range that is acceptable, rather than targeting a specific number. That way the optimizer won't spend ages trying to achieve a specific RELI value to 64-bit accuracy. Something like:
will ensure the RELI is >90% without specifying an actual target value. It also means that as long as you get the RELI you want, it doesn't affect the rest of the optimization.
Keep the sampling as small as you can, too.
Last, the Effective f/# EFNO is used in this calculation, and it may be faster to use it and just save RELI for a final system check.
HTH,
- Mark
RELI is a fairly big calculation, so I can see why it impacts speed. I'd suggest using it with an OPGT/OPLT operand so that you constrain it to be within a range that is acceptable, rather than targeting a specific number. That way the optimizer won't spend ages trying to achieve a specific RELI value to 64-bit accuracy. Something like:
will ensure the RELI is >90% without specifying an actual target value. It also means that as long as you get the RELI you want, it doesn't affect the rest of the optimization.
Keep the sampling as small as you can, too.
Last, the Effective f/# EFNO is used in this calculation, and it may be faster to use it and just save RELI for a final system check.
HTH,
- Mark
Thanks Mark,
OPGT does help significantly, I've been using that as a best practice for a while. It's one of the best tips I've gotten out of the Zemax training courses.
I will try EFNO as an indirect check. Thank you for the tip!
-Sean
OPGT does help significantly, I've been using that as a best practice for a while. It's one of the best tips I've gotten out of the Zemax training courses.
I will try EFNO as an indirect check. Thank you for the tip!
-Sean
Reply
Enter your username or e-mail address. We'll send you an e-mail with instructions to reset your password.
Need more help?
To Chinese users:
Do not provide any information or data that is restricted by applicable law, including by the People’s Republic of China’s Cybersecurity and Data Security Laws ( e.g., Important Data, National Core Data, etc.).
不要提供任何受适用法律，包括中华人民共和国的网络安全和数据安全法限制的信息或数据（如重要数据、国家核心数据等）。