At least for me, wavefront aberrations in waves are more familiar and appropriate scale for visualizing 3rd order aberrations. Especially when comparing with OPD fans. Obviously the Seidel data in mm can be converted, but it would be a nice box to tick for the bar chart!
Thanks for the consideration,
John
+2
Hi John,
If you don’t want to wait for the feature release, this data is available from the Seidel Coefficients analysis, if I’m not mistaken, which is partially supported by the ZOS-API.
In the Python ZOS-API (and it would be very similar in any other langage) you can create such an analysis:
TheSeidelCoeffs = TheSystem.Analyses.New_SeidelCoefficients()
And potentially modify its settings (see Example 17 of the ZOS-API Syntax Help File). Then, you can save the results as a text file:
TheSeidelCoeffs.GetResults().GetTextFile(“your_path.txt”)
Finally, you can parse this text file as demonstrated in this Gist (change the path to where you saved your *.txt). The result looks as below for the Double-Gauss example:
You can modify the code to customize the plot to your need, like adding horizontal bars as well, and you may want to verify what I did (cause I coded it quickly), but you get the point.
I hope this can help you.
Take care,
David
Hello David,
Thank your for the excellent assistance! I ran into an issue automating the text file generation(see end of post), but I emulated your parsing python code to archive a similar result in Matlab (file attached). Saving the text file manually isn’t much effort.
I also included removing any surfaces with all zero coefficients. And matched the OS Seidel Diagram colors for fun.
The difference in the two images below (also from 28deg Double Gauss) is helpful in illustrating my motivation for the request.
not a big deal, but this is the interactive extension error I get working from Matlab
TheSeidelCoeffs = TheSystem.Analyses.New_SeidelCoefficients();
TheSeidelCoeffs.ApplyAndWaitForCompletion();
TheSeidelCoeffs.GetResults().GetTextFile(TheApplication.SamplesDir, '\test.txt')
Error using matlab.internal.editor.evaluateCode
No method 'GetTextFile' with matching signature found for class 'ZemaxUI.ZOSAPI.Analysis.Aberrations.AR_SeidelCoefficients'.
+3
Hi John,
Thanks for the Matlab version. However, for easy interactive use during design I like your idea of simply having a checkbox option for a Seidel bar plot in waves.
To resolve your text file saving issue, try using
TheSeidelCoeffs.GetResults().GetTextFile(System.String.Concat(TheApplication.SamplesDir,'\test.txt'));or alternatively,
current_dir = cd;
TheSeidelCoeffs.GetResults().GetTextFile(System.String.Concat(current_dir,'\seidel.txt'));Regards,
Jeff
+2
This is excellent
To complement
GetTextFile(TheApplication.SamplesDir, '\test.txt')
The two strings TheApplication.SamplesDir and ‘\test.txt’ don’t get concatenated and instead, MATLAB is looking for a method GetTextFile(string, string), which takes two string as arguments, and this method doesn’t exist. You should always give GetTextFile(string) a single string argument (in the parentheses) and this string should be the result of the concatenation of your two strings. In addition to the solutions proposed by Jeff, from what I remember, you can also concatenate strings in MATLAB by using strcat(), so perhaps some thinglike this works as well (I don’t own a MATLAB licence to test):
GetTextFile(strcat(The Application.SamplesDir, ‘\test.txt’]))
And lastly, I also agree that it should be a temporary solution, ultimately it would be much better to have it as a checkbox in the user-interface.
Take care,
David
Enter your username or e-mail address. We'll send you an e-mail with instructions to reset your password.
Do not provide any information or data that is restricted by applicable law, including by the People’s Republic of China’s Cybersecurity and Data Security Laws ( e.g., Important Data, National Core Data, etc.).
不要提供任何受适用法律，包括中华人民共和国的网络安全和数据安全法限制的信息或数据（如重要数据、国家核心数据等）。